The Prism of Theology: Why the affiliated ministry We Approach Scripture Shapes What We See

A glass prism splitting sunlight into a spectrum beside an open Bible on a wooden table

TL;DR: Scripture is one truth, but our theological methods act like prisms. The questions we ask, the rules we use, and the experiences we bring to the Bible shape the doctrines we form and the fruit we produce. We need biblical truth, love, humility, personal accountability, and the willingness to let God sort out what we cannot fully know.

The prism through which we see

I know my writing is brainy at times. This one is going to be worse.

Think about light passing through a prism. Depending on the angle of the light, the hand holding the prism, and the surface receiving the light, you end up with a different color. Every viewer may honestly see the thing they say they are seeing.

So too, a different theological approach opens up potentially contradictory doctrines.

That does not mean there are different “versions of truth.” That is a heretical concept. God designed one truth, and His Word is true from the beginning (Psalm 119:160). The issue is that our methods of approaching that truth can bend what we see. Our starting assumptions, rules of interpretation, traditions, experiences, Bible versions, and expectations all affect the outcome.

The Word does not change. God does not change. Jesus Christ does not change. But erroneous belief about God or Christ does not change who they are; it changes who we are, what we do, what we expect, and what we are willing to believe is possible.

That is why theological method matters so much. In my view, the affiliated ministry theology bends often matters more than any single point of belief. Poor theological discipline can reduce God, Jesus Christ, other people, or even ourselves into shapes and contortions that are not truthful.

The lasting fruit is one confirmation we should look for. Jesus Christ said that a tree is known by its fruit (Matthew 7:15–20; Luke 6:43–45). Paul described the fruit of the spirit as love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, meekness, and temperance (Galatians 5:22–23). A theological system may be complicated or simple, highly academic or intensely practical, but the results should eventually become visible.

Books, a compass, and a glass prism arranged for Bible study in warm morning light

Sin-nature theology and holy-spirit theology

I think the bending or breaking of theology generally centers around one of two directions: a sin-nature-centered theology or a holy-spirit-focused theology.

The prophets give us an interesting parallel. Some were called to turn a nation toward repentance. Others were called to pursue the things of God with extraordinary force and faith. Their ministries did not all look the same, but God was working through different assignments in different circumstances.

All people operating in ministry have sin nature. Not all people operating in ministry have a specific calling from God upon their lives. Every Christian is called to operate the ministry of reconciliation, but specific ministers are highlighted with specific purposes in the body of Christ (2 Corinthians 5:18–20; Ephesians 4:11–16). When a gift ministry is in operation, it is often obvious. When it is absent, that can also become obvious.

At the same time, mankind is tribal. We naturally gather with people who share similar beliefs. Christian groups can become communities where people sincerely believe they are fellowshipping around the truth. Sometimes that environment produces peace, harmony, love, and believing. Sometimes it does not.

True movements of the Word produce identifiable fruit, and love is the most important fruit to observe. Paul told the Corinthians that they were spiritual infants despite their abundance of manifestations and knowledge because of the divisions among them (1 Corinthians 3:1–9). He placed love above the spectacular operation of spiritual gifts (1 Corinthians 12–14), calling love “a more excellent way” (1 Corinthians 12:31; 13:1–13).

It is easy to say there should be no schisms [divisions] in the body, and this is true (1 Corinthians 1:10–13; 12:25). One telling of the truth, properly understood and operated in the love of God, would produce one harmonious application of history and Christian living. We would have, well, peace on earth.

Sadly, that is not remotely possible in this world. I do not think the adversary would tolerate it. Once you add freedom of will, you end up with a slurry of beliefs all wearing the same banner of “Christian.” Many well-meaning people carry those banners forward, hoping to win people to Christ and fill the household of God.

Different methodologies will be practiced. But thank God it is the same Savior who does the actual heavy lifting, not our paradoxical views of the Bible.

How our beginnings shape our theology

Theology is also weighted by childhood experience. Most of us never drift completely away from those earliest stages of development. We may grow, learn, and change, but the first systems we encountered often remain beneath the surface.

I think almost every church is built this way. When you combine the temperament of a generation with the particular ministry that reaches it, the result is not difficult to understand.

Your generation rejects the systems and agencies of your parents? Your theology is going to reflect that.

Your generation loves the systems and agencies of your parents? Your theology is going to reflect that.

There is no system or agency for your parents? Your theology is going to reflect that.

I have also noticed what seems to me to be a change in Generation Alpha. My observation is that many young people are becoming more conservative and religious than the Boomer generation, which was countercultural through and through. I can see how God may be setting up a generation that will have to rebuild portions of the country.

I also see a growing desire for a stronger, more courageous expression of Christianity, rather than the softened and overly domesticated versions that have often been presented. That is a cultural observation, not a judgment against women or femininity. It is simply a recognition that the tone of Christian culture appears to be shifting.

Churches are shaped by these same forces. Regional and local reputations develop. The age of a ministry matters. A new church that began last week will not have the same history as an organized church that has operated for generations. Leadership changes bring cycles and seasons, sometimes including doctrinal changes.

It is really no different with churches than it is with families, communities, and nations.

Simple rules and serious conclusions

Personally, I believe the strongest theological arguments are rooted in the fewest rules needed to analyze Scripture and produce the result. Simplest is usually best.

For example, I believe we should allow the Word of God to provide definitions for its own words. First usage sets a helpful rule. I also believe apparent contradictions should first be examined as possible errors in our understanding or in translation before we accuse Scripture of contradicting itself.

Those are simple rules, but they can produce remarkably different conclusions. The sense of Scripture can appear dramatically transformed simply by comparing Bible versions. That is why biblical scholarship, understanding the Bible, and learning how to study the Bible require more than collecting isolated verses. We need to examine how our conclusions were formed.

Consider the question of who Jesus Christ is.

Most Christians believe that Jesus Christ is God. Many hold that belief sincerely and believe the doctrine of the Trinity faithfully explains the testimony of Scripture. In that theological system, the Trinity is a downstream result of a base theology that has roots reaching back into the early church.

Depending on how one reads history, this is either the glorious revealing of who Jesus Christ truly is or a carefully developed geopolitical and religious shift that encouraged the mass adoption of Christianity. Those are very different interpretations of the same history.

Others, including the biblical teaching I have come to accept, believe that Jesus Christ is the Messiah, the second Adam, and the Savior of mankind: a truly perfect man who accomplished what Adam could not do.

Team Jesus A and Team Jesus B can throw rocks at one another over this subject. I have participated in more debates about it than perhaps any other topic. One side may believe that accepting the Trinity is essential to salvation. The other may believe that making Jesus Christ God diminishes God’s position as the highest, prevents Christ from being the Messiah in the fullest biblical sense, and makes certain instructions difficult to understand, such as Jesus’ promise in John 14:12 that believers would do the works he did and greater works than these.

I am presenting this as a comparison of theological approaches, not as a declaration that everyone on one side is dishonest or unsaved. People on both sides love God, trust Jesus Christ, and have received salvation. But the approach we use will shape the doctrine we build from the text.

That dividing line can be traced partly to the church that first introduces a person to Christianity. Even the manner of baptism became a classic source of debate and schism.

The question is not merely, “What does this church’s statement of beliefs say?” That statement is the outcome of a theological system, not necessarily the system itself. Like the order of operations in mathematics, the system behind the statement has to be examined.

Systems and operations

The Roman Catholic theological structure cannot produce exactly the same results as a nondenominational theological structure. That is not a criticism of Catholic people. I know many very well-meaning, likely born-again individuals who participate as Roman Catholics.

My personal assessment is that any theology adding to or subtracting from the canon of Scripture is likely erroneous (Deuteronomy 4:2; Proverbs 30:5–6; Revelation 22:18–19). I also recognize that other theological systems have what seem to their participants like sound answers for why they arrived where they did.

This is why I think churches often teach doctrinal learning, the operations, without explaining the theological approach: the systems. If you do not teach people the order of operations, they can look at the same mathematical problem and produce an inaccurate answer.

Church A may have been given:

2(9x + 15) / 14

Church B may have been given:

3 + 2

They are both doing math. They are both attempting to teach the rightly divided [accurately handled] Word of God. They have both been asked to do the math by receiving salvation and endeavoring to share it with others.

Church A may look down on Church B for its erroneous doctrine and simplistic theology. Church B may look down on Church A for being boring and less immediately impactful.

Then certain phrases appear in the conversation: “always learning, and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth” (2 Timothy 3:7), “only knowing salvation,” or “it is easier to go through the eye of a needle” (Matthew 19:24).

Meanwhile, our sin-nature tendencies are measuring everyone’s inadequacies. Both churches may be wrong at the heart level.

I hate watching this, and I have been around it most of my life.

An open Bible and symbolic mathematical notes beside an unusual spatula among ordinary utensils

The ministry we need today

There is a minister I love to listen to. Doctrinally, I disagree with some of his most prominent beliefs. He clearly believes that Jesus Christ is God and that the dead are alive now. Yet he teaches identity in Christ better than any minister I have ever heard.

Some of his teachings helped me through the darkest days of my life. They helped me stand for God. If I had been so turned off by his doctrinal differences that I refused to listen, I would have missed a tremendous resource.

It is easy for someone highly educated in the Bible to become comfortable hearing the exact version of truth presented in exactly the format they have learned. It is like singing the words of a song correctly. We begin to assume that our particular presentation is the only faithful arrangement of the notes.

But reducing a truth to one format, apart from a direct quotation from Scripture, can diminish its impact through the lens of another person. This is especially true when the presentation is perfectly aligned with the generational beliefs of a particular culture.

Think of zeroing in a scope. The outcome is what it is because the proper series of lenses are in harmony.

Let us consider four examples:

  1. A 100-percent accurate teaching of the Bible gets one person born again and helps one person mature in Christ.
  2. A 70-percent accurate teaching gets one person born again and helps three people mature in Christ.
  3. A 50-percent accurate teaching gets four people born again and helps one person mature in Christ.
  4. A 25-percent accurate teaching gets ten people born again and helps no one mature in Christ.

Which is most impactful for eternity?

That is a question only God can answer. Teachers of the Bible will face serious accountability, and their reward will also be greater if they faithfully labor (James 3:1; 1 Corinthians 3:8–15). Paul’s criticism of the Corinthian church for its lack of love was more damning than his instruction about the manifestations of the spirit.

Get love right. Get busy working. Let God sort out the details as you grow up into Him.

Four objections

Someone may say, “The 100-percent accurate teaching was actually 100-percent boring. It was overly academic, long, tedious, difficult to understand, and presented without zeal.”

That matters.

Someone else may say, “The 70-percent teaching was exactly what those people needed to hear that day, so they grew more.”

Was that not also the direction of the Father, working within the minister’s best understanding to reach those three people?

Another person may say, “The 50-percent teaching was six-flags-over-Jesus that day, and the fog machine helped get people’s attention.”

So wait: you are saying the fog machine was more impactful than the Bible being taught?

And then the final case: “That last minister was not accurate about much, but his presentation of Christ as the affiliated ministry, the truth, and the life was excellent, and people accepted Christ that day.”

That is wonderful. But everything else he taught may have done little to help them mature if it was wrong.

This is what many Christians are actually choosing when they select a church, without ever stopping to think about it. They are choosing the particular subset of ministry that attracts them at that point in time. God is working within their free will and their ability to believe.

I believe there will be some highly inaccurate but heavily rewarded believers in heaven because they faithfully labored according to what they knew. I also think this is one of the wonderful puzzles God placed within Christian ministry. It makes the work endlessly complex for the adversary to counter.

The entire body of Christ has been commissioned to bring the Word to the entire world (Matthew 28:19–20). Not just one church. Not just one ministry. Not just one theological system.

The three metrics that matter

At this point, I care about three simple measures.

  1. Does this group produce new Christians?
  2. Does it help those new Christians mature in love?
  3. Does it teach personal accountability for the Christian lifestyle?

These are simplified key performance indicators rooted in the fruit of the spirit. They are not a replacement for biblical truth, but they do reveal whether biblical truth is producing practical Christianity.

Hyper-specific, highly erudite exposition may inspire one small body of Christians. A more energetic, simplified preaching of the purposes of Christ may excite another group. I am thankful to God that both exist.

The only proper way to greet another brother or sister in Christ is with love and thankfulness. Full stop.

God may look at one believer and say, “This one is tenfold.” Another may be sixtyfold. Another may be forty-two-and-a-half-fold. Another may be ninety-eightfold. Yet He loves each person who is trying to learn more about Him.

Whatever their fold, it is still a full measure.

God is the common denominator, not man. A 10/10 is still 100 percent, just like 60/60 or 42.5/42.5. It is all 100 percent within the measure given.

Someone may ask, “But Logan, wouldn’t that mean God was intentionally giving people erroneous information? Why would He not give everyone the same math problem?”

Not at all. God knows what people will and will not believe. He understands the limits of what they may or may not achieve for Him. Combined with His knowledge of who will be born and the gazillions of data points connected to each life, the inner workings of the body of Christ are something only God could orchestrate.

All things work together for good (Romans 8:28), but the output is not equally distributed because the inputs are not the same and the needs are not the same.

The entire body of Christ is setting the table. It is a death by a thousand cuts for the adversary. You may not want to eat off a spatula, but if it is the best utensil available, you are thankful that you get to eat in the first place.

We always limit God either by our understanding of His Word or by our application of the Word. He will never break our free will to give us something, or take something from us, that violates our free will.

This is why I will never say that God “uses” someone. I will say that God works in them to will and to do of His good pleasure (Philippians 2:13).

Let God sort out what we cannot know

I am personally guilty of not doing all the Word I have been taught and know to do. I have slacked off. I have become impatient. I have been overly critical. I have had hurt feelings. I have tried too hard without believing.

Sometimes the theologically rigorous teaching from Church A is exactly what I need. Other days, the “get up and move” teaching from Church B is what invigorates me. Some days Romans ministers to my heart. Other days James rebukes me for my foolishness.

I have never seen someone perfectly walk out the Christian lifestyle without any doctrinal instruction. But I have seen plenty of people receive vast amounts of doctrinal instruction with very little personal execution.

At some point, I got born again. I have been maturing for many years, with more to go. I believe I am personally responsible for living the Christian lifestyle, and I must own my outcomes.

Even that conclusion is limited. A great deal of our reward will have nothing to do with what we see each other doing. My supposition is therefore erroneous, even when it is the best I can know and assume.

We have to temper everything with love for God and reflect that love in our service to people. The real test is not whether we can love God. It is whether we can adopt that love of God into our love and service for other people.

Then we love what God loves.

We have to let God sort it out because we simply cannot know.

A fruitful vine and grapes beside an open Bible in peaceful afternoon light

The two perfect ministries

In my mind, only two ministries demonstrate what a perfect movement of God looks like.

The first is the ministry of Jesus Christ. He is the GOAT, the greatest of all time, and our permanent reference point for effective ministry. His mastery of the Old Testament Scriptures was extraordinary, and his execution of the gift upon him was perfectly optimized.

The second is Paul.

Paul does not receive this consideration because of his past as a Pharisee who persecuted Christians. Nor does he receive it because his end-of-life performance was flawless. I read the warnings in Acts 21:4 and Acts 21:10–14 as evidence that he was told not to go to Jerusalem, yet he went.

Paul receives it because his letters show different bodies of believers needing different doctrine, reproof, and correction at different phases of their lives. Those applications are not contradictory. They are different portions of the Word needed for different situations.

The Church Epistles are the gold mine of instruction for the Christian today. They are built upon the pillars of the Gospels and joined by Acts, which ties the record together. They describe the Christian life in full.

Not every believer was going to hear every letter at the same time, even though historical evidence indicates that the letters circulated among early believers. Different people received different instruction for different needs.

We should endeavor to master the Scriptures set before us personally, not because a church group goads us, but so we can stand before God as workmen of the Word (2 Timothy 2:15; 2 Timothy 3:14–17). At the same time, we should stir up the gift within us (1 Thessalonians 5:19–20; 2 Timothy 1:6) and manifest it regularly.

Christ was the one setting the theological system, so to speak. Paul was the one operating it.

God was the common denominator then, and He is no less the common denominator now.

We too should endeavor to follow the same pattern.